The Carl Kilgas Collection of China
June 14, 2023
Carl A. Kilgas was born in Wisconsin in 1905 but lived most of his life on the US Pacific Coast, first in Seattle, Washington, where he began to collect China in the 1920s. He continued to expand the collection after moving to Portland, Oregon, eventually settling in Los Angeles. Joining the very active Southern California chapter of the China Stamp Society, Carl befriended several enthusiastic China collectors and became an active supporter of the annual Los Angeles Sescal stamp exhibition, regularly supplying exhibits of small portions of his collection. Over the years, he published articles in the China Clipper from 1976 to 1985. A member of the Collectors Club of New York, he published a series of articles in the CCNY journal outlining China's postal history, with illustrations of stamps and covers of from his own collection to tell the story.
It is difficult for philatelists today to imagine what it was like collecting China in the years before the Ma Catalogue's publication in 1947. Back then, collectors had to depend on general worldwide catalogues such as Scott, Stanley Gibbons and Yvert & Tellier. Imperial China's 1878-1883 Large Dragons were listed as only three major stamps, rather than the twelve we recognize today. The Dowagers were listed as one set of nine. Other printings were regarded as mere shade varieties. The only sense we can get of how things were back in those pioneering days is from the few articles that appeared in M.D. Chow's Philatelic Bulletin, Shanghai's Asia Stamp Journal, the British Journal of Chinese Philately, the China Clipper in America, and occasional books such as Lloyd Ruland's Express Stamps and Starr-Mills Chinese Air Post.
Fortunately, a few collectors were in the right place at the right time, and had a combination of patience, technical skill, intellectual curiosity, audacity, and love of Chinese stamps. The most well-known China collection formed by a foreigner during that period was that of the American Major James Starr, whose philatelic friendship with M.D. Chow in Shanghai was supported over many years by mail, through which they exchanged ideas on subjects such as plating the Large Dragons. Major Starr died in 1949, but his collection was held intact until 1991, when it was auctioned, 42 years later.
Despite his regional activities, Carl Kilgas was unknown to the international China philatelic community. All that changed when he was asked to provide a few album pages to the 1984 Rocpex exhibition in Taipei. Over the next few years, his telephone would often ring in the middle of the night. When he picked up the handset, a voice at the other end, usually some dealer in Taiwan, would identify himself and demand to buy his China collection. This happened too often and became so annoying that Carl decided not to sell anything. Almost forty years later, we benefit from this decision since the comprehensive collection that we are now pleased to offer has remained completely untouched.
The first part of the Carl A. Kilgas collection contains selections of his extensive holding of the Large Dragons, Dowagers and Chinese Imperial Post Coiling Dragons. Additional sales will follow later this year.
We hope you enjoy these sales and good luck in bidding
Images | Description | Current Bid |
 | Lot #150 CHINA Surcharges - small numerals 2 1/2mm 1897 surcharges, complete set of nine, h.r. (some with paper hinges), fresh, fine-v.f., * Catalog #28-37 Catalog Value $2,000 | Price Realized $1,100.00
|
 | Lot #151 CHINA Surcharges - small numerals 2 1/2mm 1897 1/2c orange, fraction bar and "2" of "1/2" omitted, h.r., fresh and fine example of this scarce variety, * Catalog #28a Catalog Value $850 | Unsold
|
 | Lot #152 CHINA Surcharges - small numerals 2 1/2mm 1897 1/2c orange, fraction bar and "2" of "1/2" omitted, horizontal pair, left stamp is the variety, h.r., faint gum toning, rare se-tenant pair showing the variety in position 1 (this occurred only in the earliest printing, quickly discovered and corrected) (Chen 37i, $600) * Catalog #28,28a Catalog Value $895 | Unsold
|
 | Lot #153 CHINA Surcharges - small numerals 2 1/2mm 1897 1/2c orange, fraction bar and "2" of "1/2" omitted, block of four, upper left stamp is the variety, h.r., faint gum toning, rare se-tenant block of four showing the variety in position 1 (this occurred only in the earliest printing, quickly discovered and corrected),
* Catalog #28,28a Catalog Value $985 | Unsold
|
 | Lot #154 CHINA Surcharges - small numerals 2 1/2mm 1897 1/2c orange, fraction bar and "2" of "1/2" omitted, "Customs Canton" cancel, fine (Chen 37i, $400) O Catalog #28a Catalog Value $375 | Unsold
|
 | Lot #155 CHINA Surcharges - small numerals 2 1/2mm 1897 1/2c orange, fraction bar and "2" of "1/2" omitted, Hankow Pakua cancel, creases, fine appearance, O Catalog #28a Catalog Value $375 | Unsold
|
 | Lot #156 CHINA Surcharges - small numerals 2 1/2mm 1897 1/2c on 3c orange, top sheet margin vertical pair imperf. between stamps and at bottom, h.r. faint toning, rare (Chan 37l) * Catalog #28c Catalog Value $11,000 | Unsold
|
 | Lot #157 CHINA Surcharges - small numerals 2 1/2mm 1897 1/2c on 3c orange, block of 12, position 7 with 4mm space between Chinese characters and "1/2", mostly n.h., including variety, fine-v.f.
*/** Catalog #28,28f | Unsold
|
 | Lot #158 CHINA Surcharges - small numerals 2 1/2mm 1897 1/2c brownish yellow, horizontal gutter block of four, l.h., fine example of this elusive shade
* Catalog #28g | Unsold
|
 | Lot #159 CHINA Surcharges - small numerals 2 1/2mm 1897 1/2c on 3c brownish orange yellow, right sheet margin block of 12, position 7 with 4mm space between Chinese characters and "1/2", h.r. or n.h., some gum toning, still fine-v.f.
*/** Catalog #28g,28i | Price Realized $750.00
|
 | Lot #160 CHINA Surcharges - small numerals 2 1/2mm 1897 1c on 1can orange red, block of four, position 1 with wide space (4mm) between Chinese characters and "1", straight edge at bottom, h.r., fine-v.f., rare,
* Catalog #29,29b Catalog Value $500 | Unsold
|
 | Lot #161 CHINA Surcharges - small numerals 2 1/2mm 1897 1c and 5c surcharges, each canceled "Customs Shanghai 2 Jan 1897" (First Day of Issue), some short perfs, otherwise fine O Catalog #29,32 | Unsold
|
 | Lot #162 CHINA Surcharges - small numerals 2 1/2mm 1897 1c-10c surcharges, six different, l.h. or h.r., bottom pairs mostly n.h., fresh colors, fine-v.f.,
*/** Catalog #29-34 Catalog Value $1,520 | Price Realized $800.00
|
 | Lot #163 CHINA Surcharges - small numerals 2 1/2mm 1897 1c on 1can orange red, wide space (4mm) between Chinese characters and "1", h.r., fine, * Catalog #29b Catalog Value $500 | Price Realized $325.00
|
 | Lot #164 CHINA Surcharges - small numerals 2 1/2mm 1897 1c on 1can orange red, variety showing "1" over "e" of "Cent" (instead of over "en"), gutter at right, used, fine (Chan 38c, $300) O Catalog #29var | Unsold
|
 | Lot #165 CHINA Surcharges - small numerals 2 1/2mm 1897 2c on 2can green, double surcharge, Hankow Pakua cancel, straight edge at bottom, fine and very rare stamp, only 10 recorded, with 2023 Frumkin certificate (Chan 39c) O Catalog #30c Catalog Value $11,500 | Price Realized $7,500.00
|
 | Lot #166 CHINA Surcharges - small numerals 2 1/2mm 1897 2c on 2can green, wide space (4mm) between Chinese characters and "2", used, fine, O Catalog #30f Catalog Value $500 | Unsold
|
 | Lot #167 CHINA Surcharges - small numerals 2 1/2mm 1897 4c on 4can rose pink, double surcharge, canceled "Imperial Post Office Whampoa" date filled-in by hand "17-3-97" (earliest known!), nibbed perforations at left, fine and extremely rare double surcharge error, bearing a scarce Whampoa postmark, with 2023 Frumkin certificate (Chan 40f) O Catalog #31a Catalog Value $20,000 | Price Realized $10,500.00
|
 | Lot #168 CHINA Surcharges - small numerals 2 1/2mm 1897 5c on 5can dull orange, wide space (4mm) between Chinese characters and "5", l.h., fresh and fine, * Catalog #32b Catalog Value $800 | Price Realized $575.00
|
 | Lot #169 CHINA Surcharges - small numerals 2 1/2mm 1897 5c on 5can dull orange, 8c on 6c dark brown, each wide space (4mm) between Chinese characters and "5", used, the former thin, otherwise fine-v.f., O Catalog #32b,33d Catalog Value $1,100 | Unsold
|
 | Lot #170 CHINA Surcharges - small numerals 2 1/2mm 1897 8c on 6can dark brown, block of four, h.r., v.f.,
* Catalog #33 Catalog Value $240 | Unsold
|
 | Lot #171 CHINA Surcharges - small numerals 2 1/2mm 1897 8c on 6can dark brown, gutter block of four, n.h., v.f. (catalogued as hinged singles)
** Catalog #33 Catalog Value $240 | Unsold
|
 | Lot #172 CHINA Surcharges - small numerals 2 1/2mm 1897 8c on 6can dark brown, vertical strip of three, imperf. between and at bottom, l.h., faint toning at bottom, fresh and fine, very rare (Chan 42e) * Catalog #33b Catalog Value $15,000 | Price Realized $4,750.00
|
 | Lot #173 CHINA Surcharges - small numerals 2 1/2mm 1897 8c on 6can dark brown, variety imperf. right margin, fine (CSS 48f, used unpriced) O Catalog #33var | Unsold
|
 | Lot #174 CHINA Surcharges - small numerals 2 1/2mm 1897 10c on 9can green, upper right sheet corner margin block of eight, n.h., upper right stamp showing retouch (UR corner), minor gum toning affecting two stamps at top right, otherwise fine and impressive multiple (Chan 44,44b) (catalogued as hinged singles)
** Catalog #35,var Catalog Value $3,800 | Unsold
|
 | Lot #175 CHINA Surcharges - small numerals 2 1/2mm 1897 10c on 9can green, two distinct shades, each showing retouch at upper right corner, l.h. or h.r., fine-v.f. (catalogued as regular stamps) (Chan 44b) * Catalog #35var Catalog Value $950 | Unsold
|
 | Lot #176 CHINA Surcharges - small numerals 2 1/2mm 1897 10c on 12can brown orange, vertical pair imperf. between, canceled "Customs Shanghai" in brown ink, lightly folded between stamps, v.f. and rare variety (Chan 44e) O Catalog #36b Catalog Value $4,500 | Price Realized $3,000.00
|
 | Lot #177 CHINA Surcharges - small numerals 2 1/2mm 1897 10c on 12can brown orange, three distinct shades, h.r., one with pencil writing on back, another handstamped "Gebr.Senf. Leipzig", natural gum creases, fine-v.f., * Catalog #36 Catalog Value $1,500 | Price Realized $550.00
|
 | Lot #178 CHINA Surcharges - small numerals 2 1/2mm 1897 30c on 24can carmine, right sheet margin block of four showing engraver's centering mark ("+") at bottom right, n.h. and post office fresh, v.f. (catalogued as hinged singles) (Chan 46)
** Catalog #37 Catalog Value $2,400 | Price Realized $3,000.00
|
 | Lot #179 CHINA Surcharges - small numerals 2 1/2mm 1897 30c on 24can carmine, variety imperf. at right, margin with engraver's centering mark ("+"), h.r., faint gum toning, fine * Catalog #37var | Unsold
|
 | Lot #180 CHINA Surcharges - small numerals 2 1/2mm 1897 30c on 24can carmine, left sheet margin vertical strip of three, top two stamps with watermark inverted, bottom stamp without watermark, n.h., v.f. and unusual error (paper incorrectly fed into printing press) ** Catalog #37var | Unsold
|
 | Lot #181 CHINA Surcharges - small numerals 2 1/2mm 1897 30c on 24can carmine, faint "double surcharge" ("kiss" variety), unused without gum, creases and minor thins, fine appearance (*) Catalog #37var | Unsold
|